31 research outputs found
On Affine Logic and {\L}ukasiewicz Logic
The multi-valued logic of {\L}ukasiewicz is a substructural logic that has
been widely studied and has many interesting properties. It is classical, in
the sense that it admits the axiom schema of double negation, [DNE]. However,
our understanding of {\L}ukasiewicz logic can be improved by separating its
classical and intuitionistic aspects. The intuitionistic aspect of
{\L}ukasiewicz logic is captured in an axiom schema, [CWC], which asserts the
commutativity of a weak form of conjunction. This is equivalent to a very
restricted form of contraction. We show how {\L}ukasiewicz Logic can be viewed
both as an extension of classical affine logic with [CWC], or as an extension
of what we call \emph{intuitionistic} {\L}ukasiewicz logic with [DNE],
intuitionistic {\L}ukasiewicz logic being the extension of intuitionistic
affine logic by the schema [CWC]. At first glance, intuitionistic affine logic
seems very weak, but, in fact, [CWC] is surprisingly powerful, implying results
such as intuitionistic analogues of De Morgan's laws. However the proofs can be
very intricate. We present these results using derived connectives to clarify
and motivate the proofs and give several applications. We give an analysis of
the applicability to these logics of the well-known methods that use negation
to translate classical logic into intuitionistic logic. The usual proofs of
correctness for these translations make much use of contraction. Nonetheless,
we show that all the usual negative translations are already correct for
intuitionistic {\L}ukasiewicz logic, where only the limited amount of
contraction given by [CWC] is allowed. This is in contrast with affine logic
for which we show, by appeal to results on semantics proved in a companion
paper, that both the Gentzen and the Glivenko translations fail.Comment: 28 page
A General Framework for Sound and Complete Floyd-Hoare Logics
This paper presents an abstraction of Hoare logic to traced symmetric
monoidal categories, a very general framework for the theory of systems. Our
abstraction is based on a traced monoidal functor from an arbitrary traced
monoidal category into the category of pre-orders and monotone relations. We
give several examples of how our theory generalises usual Hoare logics (partial
correctness of while programs, partial correctness of pointer programs), and
provide some case studies on how it can be used to develop new Hoare logics
(run-time analysis of while programs and stream circuits).Comment: 27 page
Understanding and maintaining tactics graphically OR how we are learning that a diagram can be worth more than 10K LoC
The use of a functional language to implement proof strategies as proof tactics in interactive theorem provers, often provides short, concise and elegant implementations. Whilst being elegant, the use of higher order features and combinator languages often results in a very procedural view of a strategy, which may deviate significantly from the high-level ideas behind it. This can make a tactic hard to understand and hence difficult to to debug and maintain for experts and non-experts alike: one often has to tear apart complex combinations of lower level tactics manually in order to analyse a failure in the overall strategy.In an industrial technology transfer project, we have been working on porting a very large and complex proof tactic into PSGraph, a graphical language for representing proof strategies. The goal of this work is to improve understandability and maintainability of tactics. Motivated by some initial successes with this, we here extend PSGraph with additional features for development and debugging. Through the re-implementation and refactoring of several existing tactics, we demonstrates the advantages of PSGraph compared with a typical sentential tactic language with respect to debugging, readability and maintenance. In order to act as guidance for others, we give a fairly detailed comparison of the user experience with the two approaches. The paper is supported by a web page providing further details about the implementation as well as interactive illustrations of the examples
The 1st Verified Software Competition, Extended Experience Report
We, the organizers and participants, report our experiences
from the 1st Veried Software Competition, held in August 2010 in Edinburgh
at the VSTTE 2010 conferenc